Boise, ID – When it comes to iconic pizza cities, places like New York City, Chicago, and Detroit usually steal the spotlight. However, the Gem State is now making its mark on the national pizza scene. Food Network has officially recognized Piehole, Boise’s beloved late-night pizzeria, as offering the best slice of pizza in Idaho.
This accolade comes from Food Network’s popular series, “50 States of Pizza Slices,” which set out to identify the top pizza slice in every U.S. state. Amid stiff competition from states that claim pizza as part of their culinary DNA, Piehole’s inclusion is a proud moment for Idaho’s food scene, especially for late-night food lovers who frequent Downtown Boise.
How Piehole Became Idaho’s Pizza Sensation
The journey to Pizza fame began with owner Russ Crawforth, whose inspiration sparked during a 2005 trip to San Francisco. During a late-night stroll, Crawforth discovered the bustling crowds at Pizza Orgasmica at 3 a.m. Inspired by this, he envisioned creating a similar pizza culture back in Boise—delivering delicious, crave-worthy slices for those late-night drunchies.
“Owner Russ Crawforth’s inspiration for Piehole came during a trip to San Francisco in 2005. When he stumbled across the 3 a.m. crowds at Pizza Orgasmica, he saw a line stretched all the way down the block. Instantly, Crawforth knew he had to create the kind of pizza that would inspire that same late-night enthusiasm in his hometown of Boise, Idaho.”
Piehole gained praise not only for its welcoming vibe but also for its standout pizzas, particularly the uniquely Idaho slice featuring Potato and Bacon. This item is a staple on their menu and is available by the slice at both their Downtown Boise and Broadway locations.
Piehole’s popularity has transcended Boise, with expansions reaching Idaho Falls and even out-of-state cities such as Missoula, Denver, and Salt Lake City. Despite its growing footprint, local fans still cherish it as a staple of Boise’s nightlife.
Eight Underrated Boise Area Pizza Shops You Should Try
Beyond Piehole, Boise boasts a diverse range of pizza joints that deserve more recognition. Here are eight highly recommended local spots, voted by the community, that offer unique and delicious pizzas:
- Red Bench Pizza: Known for their Gluten Free Thin Crust and Cauliflower Crust options, offering free local delivery without third-party fees.
- Guido’s: A downtown gem offering classic New York-style slices sold by the slice—perfect for solo eaters.
- Pizza Twist: Opens in a former Pizza Hut location, featuring vegan, keto, halal options, and Indian-inspired flavors like Lamb Kabob and Chicken Tikka Masala.
- Messenger Pizza: A funky Nampa spot with standout pizzas like “Toga Party” and Apple Bacon pesto pie, reminiscent of East Coast-style thin crust.
- Johnny Bronx Pizza: Meridian’s New York-style drive-thru known for using filtered water to replicate NYC’s dough taste.
- Garbonzo’s Pizza: Famous for hand-tossed dough aged for flavor, serving Chicago deep dish and inventive pies.
- Keystone Pizza: A Caldwell institution, known for inventive creations like the Monterey Chicken white sauce pizza.
- Digg’s Pizza: The most underrated gem with over 20 years of pizza craft, known for creative pies like “The Whole Enchilada” and fresh hand-tossed dough.
Piehole’s Place in Idaho’s Pizza Landscape
Piehole stands out not just for its delicious slices but also for capturing the spirit of Boise’s nightlife and culinary culture. Its recognition by Food Network puts Idaho on the pizza map, showing that great slices can come from anywhere—even the Gem State.
Whether you’re craving a greasy late-night fix or simply want to try something different, Piehole and these underrated Boise pizza shops offer a slice for every palate.
For more detailed insights about Piehole and the top Idaho pizza spots, check out the full story on NewsBreak.
What Do You Think About Idaho’s Pizza Scene?
Food lovers, what’s your favorite Boise pizza spot? Have you tried Piehole’s famous Potato/Bacon slice, or do you have another hidden gem on your list? Share your thoughts and pizza experiences in the comments below!
